Back to the Main Page




Addendum: Chinese Migration in Primorskii Krai: An Assessment of Its Scale, Socioeconomic Impact, and Opportunities for Corruption


Table A1. Number of PRC Citizens Employed in Primorskii Krai
 
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
      
Primorye total
7895
8349
8292
6968
7179
Artem  
134
220
190
Arseniev  
0
0
0
Vladivostok  
1580
1513
1483
Nakhodka  
1743
951
951
Partizansk  
166
145
140
Ussuriisk  
1578
1997
1929
Dal'nerechenskii r-n  
118
48
85
Kirovskii r-n  
0
0
15
Lesozavodskii r-n  
6
3
61
Nadezhdinskii r-n  
150
92
202
Oktiabrskii r-n  
500
1023
1135
Partizanskii r-n  
372
143
111
Pogranichnyi r-n  
393
74
30
Pozharskii r-n  
286
31
48
Spasskii r-n  
192
128
179
Ussuriyskii r-n  
0
0
0
Khankaiskii r-n  
151
174
179
Khasanskii r-n  
263
4
2
Khorol'skii r-n  
122
134
81
Shkotovskii r-n  
65
19
59
      
Total listed by city  
5201
4826
4693
Total listed by raion  
2618
1873
2187
Total listed  
7819
6699
6880
Listed as % of Primor'e  
94
96
96
Cities as % of Primor'e  
63
69
65
NOTE: No data was collected by city and raion in 1994 and 1995
SOURCE: Goskomstat Rossiiskoi Federatsii, Primorskii kraevoi komitet gosudarstvennoi statistiki, No. 19sv-39, May 28, 1999.

Back to the top.

Table A2. Production of Principal Consumer Items in Primorskii krai, 1990-1997.
Area Item
1990
1994
1997
1997-to-1990, %
Primorskii krai Garments (000s)
14918
1177
80
0.5
Primorskii krai Shoes (000s pairs)
2127
556
28
1.3
Primorskii krai Refrigerators
151545
23185
0
0.0
Primorskii krai Washing machines
116179
16433
37
0.03
Primorskii krai Kitchenware (000s) 
29984
9341
1041
3.5
Primorskii krai Soap (tons)
27475
4107
835
3.0
Artem Garments (000s)
14668
991
80
0.5
Artem Kitchenware (000s) 
7916
1779
0
0.0
Vladivostok Garments (000s)
250
186
0
0.0
Vladivostok Dishes (000s) 
22068
7562
1041
4.7
Ussuriisk Shoes (000s pairs)
2127
556
28
1.3
Ussuriisk Refrigerators
151545
23185
0
0.0
Ussuriisk Soap (tons)
27475
4107
835
3.0
Arseniev Washing machines
116179
16433
37
0.03
SOURCE: Goskomstat Rossiiskoi Federatsii, Primorskii kraevoi komitet gosudarstvennoi statistiki, Sotsial'naia sfera gorodov i raionov Primorskogo kraia (Vladivostok, 1998), 78.

Back to the top.

Table A3. Agricultural Output for All Types of Producers, 1990-1997 (kilograms/number per capita).
Meat
Milk
Eggs
Vegetables
1990
1997
1990
1997
1990
1997
1990
1997
Primorye total
37
9.4
163
67
291
133
44
42
Artem
120
25
63
26
2500
1211
86
107
Arseniev
7
1.1
1
6
8
0.1
17
14
Vladivostok
2
0.1
1
0.4
0.5
0.1
8
8
Nakhodka
4
0.6
5
3
4
0
6
20
Partizansk
19
3.5
76
30
25
5
53
28
Ussuriysk (city&raion)
32
6
150
60
108
65
76
40
Dalnerechenskii raion
51
14
273
101
404
269
29
21
Kirovskii r-n
86
29
613
209
64
66
55
57
Lesozavodskii r-n
47
15
332
125
40
33
41
66
Nadezhdinskii r-n
175
21
307
125
2348
157
130
151
Oktiabrskii r-n
93
22
558
199
93
37
216
104
Partizanskii r-n
77
21
497
148
1631
557
206
149
Pogranichnyi r-n
116
22
618
269
1488
102
105
39
Pozharskii r-n
31
10
227
84
57
35
41
43
Spasskii r-n
54
13
313
122
63
48
87
38
Khankaiskii r-n
138
41
747
344
132
71
40
44
Khasanskii r-n
23
7
118
67
33
18
24
12
Khorol'skii r-n
100
34
575
237
509
198
30
45
Shkotovskii r-n
11
12
66
149
25
56
26
155

Back to the top.

Table A4. Average Monthly Wages, Indexed to 1991 Prices.
 
1993
1997
Change
Primorye total
53
37
-16
Artem
61
44
-17
Arseniev
48
21
-27
Vladivostok
60
39
-21
Nakhodka
55
39
-16
Partizansk
66
40
-26
Ussuriisk (city&raion)
48
29
-19
Dal'nerechenskii raion
42
28
-14
Kirovskii r-n
49
23
-26
Lesozavodskii r-n
49
30
-19
Nadezhdinskii r-n
54
31
-23
Oktiabr'skii r-n
49
31
-18
Partizanskii r-n
55
34
-21
Pogranichnyi r-n
39
27
-12
Pozharskii r-n
57
56
-1
Spasskii r-n
33
20
-13
Khankaiskii r-n
37
26
-11
Khasanskii r-n
45
31
-14
Khorol'skii r-n
50
23
-27
Shkotovskii r-n
37
28
-9
SOURCE: Goskomstat Rossiiskoi Federatsii, Primorskii krayevoi komitet gosudarstvennoi statistiki, Sotsial'naia sfera gorodov i raionov Primorskogo kraia (Vladivostok, 1998), …..

Back to the top.

Table A5. Number of Joint Ventures with PRC.
 
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
Artem
1
2
1
1
1
 
Arseniev  
1
1
1
 
Vladivostok
5
6
22
27
23
10
Nakhodka
5
15
27
32
24
10
Partizansk  
1
1
1
 
Ussuriisk 
3
7
6
6
5
Dal'nerechenskii r-n  
1
3
4
3
Kirovskii r-n      
Lesozavodskii r-n  
1
1
1
1
Nadezhdinskii r-n
1
2
2
2
1
 
Oktiabr'skii r-n      
Partizanskii r-n      
Pogranichnyi r-n 
1
1
1
1
1
Pozharskii r-n      
Spasskii r-n     
1
Ussuriyskii r-n     
1
Khankaiskii r-n      
Khasanskii r-n  
1
1
1
1
Khorol'skii r-n      
Shkotovskii r-n  
1
   
       
Total listed
12
29
66
76
64
33
SOURCE: Goskomstat Rossiiskoi Federatsii, Primorskii kraevoi komitet gosudarstvennoi statistiki, No. 19sv-39, May 28, 1999.

Back to the top.

Table A6. Goods Produced and Services Rendered by Russian-PRC JVs in Primorskii Krai (by volume, in thousands of roubles).
 
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
Artem
10.1
135.2
737.8
395
386
 
Arseniev  
43.7
53
2
 
Vladivostok
220
1162.3
4160.3
5016.2
3564.7
7461
Nakhodka
67
1154
10459.6
9894.3
5083.1
4192.9
Partizansk  
235.8
163
  
Ussuriisk 
206.2
454
1987
6722
 
Dalnerechenskii raion    
246.8
4077.3
Lesozavodskii r-n  
1584.8
7684.5
3362
548
Nadezhdinskii r-n
72.9
512.2
682.5
378.6
460.4
 
Oktiabrskii r-n      
Pogranichnyi r-n   
65
186
109
Spasskii r-n     
93.1
Ussuriyskii r-n     
3065.5
Khankaiskii r-n  
16
89
176
436
       
Total listed
370
3169.9
18374.5
25725.6
20189
19982.8
SOURCE: Goskomstat Rossiiskoi Federatsii, Primorskii kraevoi komitet gosudarstvennoi statistiki, No. 19sv-39, May 28, 1999.

Back to the top.

Table A7. Goods Sold by Russian-PRC JVs in Primorskii Krai (millions of rubles).
 
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
Artem 
42.9
1561
798
948
Arseniev  
314.7
216
13
Vladivostok 
785.1
4822.8
10491.9
10300
Nakhodka
10.6
305.7
6514.4
15477.8
6972.7
Ussuriisk  
711.3
1322.3
7414
Dalnerechenskii raion   
1169.8
 
Nadezhdinskii r-n 
162.2
617.8
1426.4
705
Partizanskii r-n  
235.8
445
 
Pogranichnyi r-n   
24
126
Khankaiskii r-n  
77.5
274
401.4
SOURCE: Goskomstat Rossiiskoi Federatsii, Primorskii kraevoi komitet gosudarstvennoi statistiki, No. 19sv-39, May 28, 1999.

Back to the top.

Table A8. Chinese Migrant Workers and Vegetable Production in Primor'e, 1996-97.
 
Migrant workers
(% labor force)
Vegetable Output
(kg per capita)
Migrant Workers
Vegetable Output
Area
1996
1997
1996
1997
1997-to-96 Ratio
1997-to-96 Ratio
Artem
0.3
0.7
136
107
1.33
-0.21
Arseniev
0
0
19
14
0.00
-0.26
Vladivostok
0.5
0.5
9
8
0.00
-0.11
Nakhodka
2.2
1.2
28
20
-0.45
-0.29
Partizansk
0.8
0.8
41
28
0.00
-0.32
Ussuriisk
2.4
3.2
0
0
0.33
0.00
Dal’nerechenskii r-n
0.7
0.4
22
21
-0.43
-0.05
Kirovskii r-n
0
0
76
57
0.00
-0.25
Lesozavodskii r-n
0
0
73
66
0.00
-0.10
Nadezhdinskii r-n
1.3
0.8
235
151
-0.38
-0.36
Oktiabr’skii r-n
4.9
11
111
104
1.24
-0.06
Partizanskii r-n
5.7
2.3
248
149
-0.60
-0.40
Pogranichnyi r-n
6.1
1.2
56
39
-0.80
-0.30
Pozharskii r-n
1.9
0.2
45
43
-0.89
-0.04
Spasskii r-n
0.7
0.6
76
38
-0.14
-0.50
Ussuriiskii r-n
0
0
58
40
0.00
-0.31
Khankaiskii r-n
1.7
2.2
53
44
0.29
-0.17
Khasanskii r-n
1.9
0
15
12
-1.00
-0.20
Khorol'skii r-n
0.9
1.1
69
45
0.22
-0.35
Shkotovskii r-n
1
1
82
155
0.00
0.89
           
AVERAGE
1.65
1.36
72.6
57.05
-0.1
-0.2
1997 as % of 1996 
82
 
79
   
SOURCES: Goskomstat Rossiiskoi Federatsii, Primorskii kraevoi komitet gosudarstvennoi statistiki, No. 19sv-39, May 28, 1999. Goskomstat Rossiiskoi Federatsii, Primorskii krayevoi komitet gosudarstvennoi statistiki, Sotsial'naia sfera gorodov i raionov Primorskogo kraia (Vladivostok, 1998), …..

Back to the top.

Table A9. Chinese Migrant Labor and Individual Housing Construction in Primorskii Krai.
Migrant workers
(% labor force)
Individual Housing Construction
(Houses per capita)
Migrant
Workers
Housing
Construction
Area
1996
1997
1996
1997
1997-to-96 Ratio
1997-to-96 Ratio
Artem
0.3
0.7
2.7
6.2
0
3.5
Arseniev
0
0
0
0.2
0
0.2
Vladivostok
0.5
0.5
4.8
7
-1
2.2
Nakhodka
2.2
1.2
4.9
4.3
0
-0.6
Partizansk
0.8
0.8
2
1.9
0.8
-0.1
Ussuriisk
2.4
3.2
1.4
3.6
-0.3
2.2
Dal’nerechenskii r-n
0.7
0.4
0
0.2
0
0.2
Kirovskii r-n
0
0
0.9
0.6
0
-0.3
Lesozavodskii r-n
0
0
0.1
0.5
-0.5
0.4
Nadezhdinskii r-n
1.3
0.8
3.2
4.2
6.1
1
Oktiabr’skii r-n
4.9
11
1.9
1.2
-3.4
-0.7
Partizanskii r-n
5.7
2.3
1.3
1.3
-4.9
0
Pogranichnyi r-n
6.1
1.2
0.3
0.1
-1.7
-0.2
Pozharskii r-n
1.9
0.2
0.4
0.8
-0.1
0.4
Spasskii r-n
0.7
0.6
1.4
1.8
0
0.4
Ussuriiskii r-n
0
0
0.8
1.4
0.5
0.6
Khankaiskii r-n
1.7
2.2
0.3
2.1
-1.9
1.8
Khasanskii r-n
1.9
0
1.8
0.5
0.2
-1.3
Khorol'skii r-n
0.9
1.1
0.5
0.3
0
-0.2
Shkotovskii r-n
1
1
1.5
1.1
0
-0.4
             
Total    
30.2
39.3
   
Averages
1.65
1.36
1.51
1.97
   
1997 as % of 1996  
82
 
130
   
SOURCES: Goskomstat Rossiiskoi Federatsii, Primorskii kraevoi komitet gosudarstvennoi statistiki, No. 19sv-39, May 28, 1999.
Goskomstat Rossiiskoi Federatsii, Primorskii krayevoi komitet gosudarstvennoi statistiki, Sotsial'naia sfera gorodov i raionov Primorskogo kraia (Vladivostok, 1998), …..

Back to the top.

Table A10a. Outcomes of Environmental Violation Inspections by the "Tigr" Department, State Committee on Environmental Protection for Primorskii krai, 1994-1998.

Staff

Measurement unit

1994

1995

1996

1997

1998

"Tigr" staff size

8

> 8--17

17--20--18

18--16

22-20


Table A10b. Outcomes of Environmental Violation Inspections by the "Tigr" Department, State Committee on Environmental Protection for Primorskii krai, 1994-1998.
Registered Violations No. of cases 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998

Total:

164

171

229

270

639

Hunting rules

85

80

149

133

151

Fishing rules

20

26

36

109

300

Forest use rules

0

13

19

28

89

Fire safety

0

0

0

0

7

Pollution rules

0

0

0

0

37

Bioresource use

0

0

0

0

11



Table A10c. Outcomes of Environmental Violation Inspections by the "Tigr" Department, State Committee on Environmental Protection for Primorskii krai, 1994-1998.
Activities Measurement unit 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998

Filed Criminal Cases

3

5

15

5

54


Table A10d. Outcomes of Environmental Violation Inspections by the "Tigr" Department, State Committee on Environmental Protection for Primorskii krai, 1994-1998.
Confiscated tools Measurement unit 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998

Tiger traps

0

0

0

1

1

Fishing nets

0

31

90

318

470

Traps and snares

0

0

32

40

54

Firearms

46

82

143

105

146


Table A10e. Outcomes of Environmental Violation Inspections by the "Tigr" Department, State Committee on Environmental Protection for Primorskii krai, 1994-1998.
Confiscated bioproducts Measurement unit 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998

Tiger skins & skeletons

14

2

4

11

2

Leopard skins

0

0

2

0

2

Furry animal skins

0

0

0

3

4

Meat of hoofed animals

No. of animals killed

0

0

8

29

8

Bear gall

No.\grams

0

0

0

0

2\25

Musk deer sex glands

0

0

0

0

87

Wild ginseng

No. of roots

2559

6000

5515

11912

31932

Dried frogs

Kilograms

0

0

0

150

0

Dried sea cucumber

Kilograms

284

14

180

120

748

Timber

Cubic meters

0

10

0

160

469

Sea urchins

0

0

0

0

100

Fish

Kilograms

0

0

400

55

496

Sea scallops

Kilograms

0

0

0

0

5

Salmon roe

Kilograms

0

0

0

0

126

Drug plants

Hectars

0

0

0

1.5

0

Drug plants

No. of plants

0

0

0

7100

0

Marijuana

Kilograms

0

0

0

20

21.4

SOURCE: Rezul'taty kontrol'no-inspetsionnoi deyatel'nosti otdela "Tigr" Goskomekologii Primorskogo kraia za period s aprelia 1994 po dekabr' 1998 gg. Compiled by B.I. Litvinov, Deputy head of the "Tigr" deparment, 1999.

Back to the top.

Table A11. Size, Density and Population Dynamics in Primorskii krai, 1993-1998.
1993
1998
1993-98 Decline 1993-98 DeclineDensity, 1998ReproductionMigration**MigrationDemographic Insecurity
('000)
('000)
('000)
(%)
(per sq. km)*
(per '000,
1990-97 change)
(1992-97 total)
(1992-97 
change % '93 population)
(Based on % decline, density, reproduction 
and migration %)
Primor'e total
2286.9
2196.5
90.4
4
13.6
-9.7
-36922
-1.6
WeakStrong
Artem
115.2
113.6
1.6
1.4
224
-11.1
1939
1.7
3
1
Arseniev
70.8
67.1
3.7
5.2
1731
-9.6
-1588
-2.2
2
2
Vladivostok
664
642.4
21.6
3.3
1148
-8.4
-13730
-2.1
3
1
Nakhodka
193
189.1
3.9
2
583
-9.1
-1246
-0.6
4
0
Partizansk
61.6
59.6
2
3.2
46
-9.9
1740
2.8
4
0
Ussuriisk, city & raion
192.7
187.5
5.2
2.7
955
-8.8
2930
1.5
4
0
Dalnerechenskii raion*
57.3
53
4.3
7.5
2.1
-11.3
-2496
-4.4
0
4
Kirovskii r-n
30.4
28.8
1.6
5.3
7.8
-13.6
-1011
-3.3
0
4
Lesozavodskii r-n*
58.5
56
2.5
4.3
3.5
-12.5
-774
-1.3
2
2
Nadezhdinskii r-n
43.2
43
0.2
0.5
27.1
-10.9
803
1.9
4
0
Oktiabrskii r-n
39.9
37.8
2.1
5.3
24.2
-9.4
249
0.6
4
0
Partizanskii r-n
29.6
30.8
-1.2
-4.1
7.3
-10
2372
8.0
3
1
Pogranichnyi r-n
27
24.4
2.6
9.6
6.6
-8.1
-752
-2.8
1
3
Pozharskii r-n
38
36.8
1.2
3.2
1.7
-12.4
184
0.5
2
2
Spasskii r-n*
93.9
889
5
5.3
7.3
-11.9
-409
-0.4
1
3
Khankaiskii r-n
29.9
27.7
2.2
7.4
10.4
-10.8
-1533
-5.1
1
3
Khasanskii r-n
44.3
41.2
3.1
7
10.4
-11.4
-2307
-5.2
0
4
Khorol'skii r-n
43.7
39.6
4.1
9.4
20.6
-9.9
-2608
-6.0
2
2
Shkotovskii r-n*
74.9
68.8
6.1
8.1
10.6
-11.7
-2165
-2.9
0
4
Ussuriyskii r-n
30.9
29.1
1.8
5.8
8.5
-12.4
-893
-2.9
0
4
           
Average, border raions 
43.3
 
5.3
10.6
-11.2
-810.0
-1.7
  
Average 
93.3
 
4.6
241.8
-10.7
-1064.8
-1.1
  
  *Population density and migration under Ussuriisk city & raion is for Ussuriisk city only.
**Refers to in (+) or out (-) migration predominantly of ethnic Russians and Ukrainians
SOURCE: Goskomstat Rossiiskoi Federatsii, Primorskii krayevoi komitet gosudarstvennoi statistiki, Sotsial'naia sfera gorodov i raionov Primorskogo kraia (Vladivostok, 1998), 9, 10, 14, 16.

Back to the top.


Table A12a. Positive Socioeconomic Incentives for Supporting Cross-Border Interactions with PRC Nationals in Primor'e (1997-1998).
  Consumer goods Food availability  Income/savings Investment/
Joint ventures
JV vs. taxes
(Corruption
incentives)
JV-taxes
(Corruption
incentives)
Smuggling
(Corruption
incentives)
Total  Corruption incentives
Indicator: Production decline Agricultural output declineAverage wage declineJV indicators Peak-to-1998Foreign trade Domestic tradeIllicit trade      
Source:Table A2Table A3Table A4Tables 2, Fig. 1Table 3Table 4Table A11 (columns b-h) (columns f-h) 
ArtemStrongStrongStrongWeakWeakStrongWeakStrongWeak1 strong
ArsenievStrongStrongStrongWeakWeakWeakWeakWeakWeak 
VladivostokStrongStrongStrongStrongStrongStrongVariableStrongStrong1 variable
Nakhodka StrongWeakVariableVariableStrongWeakWeakWeak1 strong
PartizanskStrongStrongStrongWeakWeakWeakWeakWeakWeak 
Ussuriisk (city&raion)StrongStrongStrongStrongStrongStrongStrongStrongStrong 
Dalnerechenskii raion StrongWeakStrongStrongWeakStrongStrongStrong1 weak
Kirovskii r-n WeakStrongWeakWeakWeakWeakWeakWeak 
Lesozavodskii r-n StrongStrongWeakWeakWeakStrongStrongWeak1 strong
Nadezhdinskii r-n StrongStrongVariableStrongWeakWeakStrongWeak1 strong
Oktiabrskii r-n StrongStrongWeakWeakWeakWeakWeakWeak 
Partizanskii r-n StrongWeakWeakWeakWeakWeakWeakWeak 
Pogranichnyi r-n StrongWeakWeakWeakStrongWeakWeakWeak1 strong
Pozharskii r-n WeakWeakWeakWeakWeakWeakWeakWeak 
Spasskii r-n StrongWeakWeakWeakWeakWeakWeakWeak 
Khankaiskii r-n WeakWeakWeakWeakWeakWeakWeakWeak 
Khasanskii r-n StrongWeakWeakWeakWeakStrongWeakWeak1 strong
Khorol'skii r-n WeakStrongWeakWeakWeakWeakWeakWeak 
Shkotovskii r-n WeakWeakWeakWeakWeakWeakWeakWeak 
Strong = above average
Weak = below average
 
Table A12b. Negative Socioeconomic Incentives for Supporting Cross-Border Interactions with PRC Nationals in Primor'e (1997-1998).
 
Demographic Insecurity
Job Competition
Environmental Grievances
TOTAL
Indicator:
% decline, density,
reproduction and migration %
Job-seekers per
vacancy
Bioresource Sensitivity
 
Source:
Table 11A
Table 7
Table 8
 
 
Weak
Strong
Strongest
Strong (+)
 
 
Primorye total      
Artem
3
1
    
Arseniev
2
2
 
+
 
+
Vladivostok
3
1
    
Nakhodka
4
0
    
Partizansk
4
0
    
Ussuriisk (city&raion)
4
0
    
Dalnerechenskii raion
0
4
+
 
+
++
Kirovskii r-n
0
4
+
+
+
+++
Lesozavodskii r-n
2
2
    
Nadezhdinskii r-n
4
0
    
Oktiabrskii r-n
4
0
    
Partizanskii r-n
3
1
    
Pogranichnyi r-n
1
3
+
 
+
++
Pozharskii r-n
2
2
  
+
+
Spasskii r-n
1
3
+
  
+
Khankaiskii r-n
1
3
+
+
+
+++
Khasanskii r-n
0
4
+
+
+
+++
Khorol'skii r-n
2
2
    
Shkotovskii r-n
0
4
+
 
+
++
Ussuriiskii r-n
0
4
+
 
+
++

Back to the top.



Back to the Main Page